Whether it’s become relevant to your own life recently or you were just curious, you want to know what compensatory damages are.
Fortunately, you’ve come to the right place. We’re going to give you the rundown on compensatory damages, but not just what those words mean, we’ll also provide examples and cite some relevant case law to show you how compensatory damages work in the real world.
Of course, the real world is complicated and what may be called compensatory damages can differ between states and other sub-jurisdictions like counties, so we’ll try to be as in-depth as possible with our explanation while keeping it brief.
What Are Compensatory Damages?
Compensatory damage is an amount of money awarded to a successful plaintiff who manages to prove, in a court of law, that they have struggled with physical or financial hardship as a result of a loss that was the defendant’s responsibility.
In short, if someone’s negligence or illegal acts have led to your discomfort, a civil court can award you a lump sum of cash for the difficulties you have faced.
Proving that these damages have taken place in court can vary depending on what basis the damages have been claimed. They’ll all involve first proving the damages occurred in the first place, and then second proving that it’s the defendant’s fault.
How much you get for compensatory damages will depend on the incident and the culpability and status of the defendant. You will have to quantify the loss from damages in the eyes of both the judge and a jury of your peers, which may need homework if you want to build a strong case.
You should keep in mind that this sum is set in stone. Compensatory damages are not punitive damages where there’s the possibility of being awarded more than you asked for.
The best-case scenario for actual compensatory damages filing is you get exactly what you had asked of the court, while general compensatory damages can award more depending on how the court breaks down your loss estimations.
Actual And General Compensatory Damages
Compensatory damages come under actual or general. As we explained above, actual compensatory damages are more rigid cases where the plaintiff brings into the courthouse a set amount that they are suing for, and that set amount is rewarded if they prove their case.
Think of actual compensatory damages as setting a monetary goal ahead of you and, through providing sufficient arguments and evidence in court, you must prove that the losses you’ve experienced add up to that goal.
Because of this standard, actual compensatory damages are usually suing for loss of income or other provable financial issues while general compensatory damages handle more personal complaints.
General compensatory damages aren’t so rigid. General compensatory damages cases are able to use methods at their discretion to pay more than the sum total of losses. This is done in one of two ways, the multiplier method or the per diem method.
The multiplier method takes proven damages and, in the case of injury or serious harm caused to the plaintiff, they’ll divide the actual damages by a number meant to correspond to how grievous the injury or disruption was.
If you’ve wiped the dust off of your Latin, you may have figured that the per diem method revolves around days. In these cases, the court will attach a price to every day that the plaintiff suffered their loss. This is usually one dollar.
Then they add all of the days up, resulting in a system that awards more to those who have been more grievously offended.
Every court is different, so there may be slight variations or mixing of the methodology used, but they’ll generally fall into one of the two camps.
There are other damages too, we’ve already mentioned one with punitive damages. Punitive, equitable, and restitution damages are other damages forms that don’t file under compensatory damages.
Examples Of Compensatory Damages
Many people learn by example, so perhaps giving you some real-world examples of what would come under compensatory damages will help.
We’ve got examples of both actual and general compensatory damages below so that every possible situation has been covered.
Actual Compensatory Damage Examples
- Medical treatments, including hospital bills and ambulance expenses
- Physical therapy or rehabilitation
- Medical equipment and prescription drugs
- Lost employment income or wages
- Replacement or repair of property
- Cover transportation costs
General Compensatory Damage Examples
- Future lost wages or medical expenses
- Long-term physical pain and suffering
- Mental anguish or loss of enjoyment of life
- Loss of opportunity
As you can see, general compensatory damages are much more personal in nature.
This can make them harder to assess too since it takes into account personal facts about the plaintiff that will be different across every case as the plaintiffs change.
Compensatory Damages In Practice
So how does a compensatory damages case look? Fortunately for us, compensatory damages cases are all too common in civil court decisions, so we have a lot to look at if we want to find examples.
We’ll try to stick to a case that best represents how one of these cases can play out, no matter which state you’re in.
First, many compensatory damages cases that have merit don’t even make it to court. They often get settled out of court long before it comes to those legal procedures.
That said, when these cases do hit the courts, the damages must be proven to have negatively harmed the plaintiff with a definable injury. Expert evidence is possibly involved if the case isn’t so clear cut, too.
Speaking of cases that aren’t clear cut, let’s dive into an example of a compensatory damages case. That’d be Aref V. Lynch, where appellants and federal prisoners Yassin Aref, Kifah Jayyousi, and Daniel McGowan raised a case over their containment in communication management units, or CMUs, for years.
These CMUs prohibited family contact and other means of communication with the rest of the world, which was argued to be a violation of due process and worthy of damages under the Prison Litigation Reform Act, or the PLRA.
The injuries outlined included “loss of educational opportunity in the form of release preparation programming, reputational harm, violation of their First Amendment rights, and lasting harm to their familial relationships.”
The reason this case got complicated was the Limitation on Recovery section of the PLRA. It states that “No Federal civil action may be brought by a prisoner confined in a jail, prison, or other correctional facility, for mental or emotional injury suffered while in custody without a proper showing of physical injury.”
Counterarguments to this included that a constitutional violation did occur and that this itself is a type of mental or emotional injury, hence why unconstitutional actions are treated so seriously.
Ultimately, the court decided with the established reading of the PLRA’s Limitation on Recovery, so the court held that actual but intangible harms had occurred but the case failed since the prison official central to the case had qualified immunity.
This is a case that split the circuit but they eventually agreed that prisoner claims must be themselves split into injuries alleged or relief sought.
That’s probably as complicated as a compensatory case can get since it involves prisoners, the ever-changing prisoner treatment legislations, claims of first amendment violations, and a member of the case having qualified immunity.
The overwhelming majority of these cases would never get so complicated, so don’t be discouraged if you think you have a case.
Thank you for visiting. This website is for informational purposes only. None of the information provided is intended to constitute, nor does it constitute, legal advice, and none of the information necessarily reflects the opinions of Misty Rock Capital LLC dba whocanisue.com or anyone associated, employed or affiliated with Misty Rock Capital LLC dba whocanisue.com.